The Difference Between a Psychologist and a Psychiatrist
People often ask me, “What is the difference between a psychologist and a psychiatrist?” While the titles may sound similar, and some job functions are the same, the educational paths that these two professionals take are quite different.
Psychologist vs. Psychiatrist
- Psychiatrists are medical doctors. They have either an M.D. or a D.O. (Doctor of Osteopathy). Their basic medical school training is the same curriculum that all medical doctors receive, be they general practitioners or obstetricians, but psychiatrists then receive specialized training in treating mental illness. While psychiatrists are qualified to offer psychotherapy, most limit their practice to medication evaluations.
- Psychologists also have a doctoral degree, usually a Ph.D. or a Psy.D. (Doctor of Psychology) in Clinical or Counseling Psychology and their graduate school training focuses on the practice of psychology including making psychiatric diagnoses, administering psychological tests, and performing psychotherapy. Ph.D programs also train psychologists to conduct research in the field of mental health. They are trained in psychological and educational assessment. Generally, psychologists cannot prescribe medication, although a few states allow for this after extra training. School psychologists typically hold an Ed.D (Doctor of Education) and often work within a school system. Their focus is less on providing treatment of mental health problems and more on helping students function in a school environment, make good educational choices.
Both psychiatrists and psychologists must be licensed in the state where they practice in order to use these titles. The total time involved for education and training experiences after receiving a bachelor’s degree until licensure for both fields is about 8 years.
Other Mental Health Counseling Careers and Education Paths
There are several other degree paths to becoming a mental health professional that do not require a doctorate. These include a master’s in clinical mental health counseling, a master’s in clinical social work, and a master’s in psychiatric nursing. Although the training in psychotherapy is generally the same among these fields, and the time it takes to earn the degrees are roughly equivalent, each has its own unique professional identity and therefore takes a different approach to dealing with mental health.
- Clinical Mental Health Counselor – Typically, professional counselors have an M.A. (Master of Arts) or an M.S. (Master of Science), although school counselors usually have an M.Ed. (Masters of Education). Generally, these degrees require 2-3 years of coursework including an internship. The philosophy of counseling focuses on the growth of the client more so than the client’s symptoms. The American Counseling Association defines counseling as “a professional relationship that empowers diverse individuals, families and groups to accomplish mental health, wellness, education and career goals.”
Becoming licensed to practice independently requires another 1-2 years of post-master’s supervised work experience.
- Clinical Social Worker – According to the National Association of Social Workers, “Clinical social work is a specialty practice area of social work which focuses on the assessment, diagnosis, treatment and prevention of mental illness, emotional, and other behavioral disturbances. Individual, group and family therapy are common treatment modalities.” To become a licensed clinical social worker also requires 2-3 years of coursework and another 1-2 years of supervised clinical work experience.
- Psychiatric Nurse Practitioner – The American Psychiatric Nurse Association states, “Psychiatric Mental Health Advanced Practice Registered Nurses (PMH-APRNs) offer primary care services to the psychiatric-mental health population. PMH-APRNs assess, diagnose and treat individuals and families with psychiatric disorders or the potential for such disorders using their full scope of therapeutic skills, including the prescription of medication and administration of psychotherapy.”
The path to this profession begins with earning a Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) as an undergraduate degree. A Master of Science in Nursing (MSN) is the minimum requirement to become a nurse practitioner which takes a minimum of 2 years after the BSN. The Doctorate in Nursing Practice (DNP) is now becoming more common which requires at least 4 years of study after the BSN. Significant clinical experience is an important part of the training. All states require a license to practice as a psychiatric nurse practitioner and some states require oversight by a physician.
Dr. Marc Wilson has been an educator for over 30 years, serving in a variety of roles including professor, department chair, and academic dean. He is currently Executive Director of Counseling Programs at Southern New Hampshire University where he previously worked as the Director of Accreditation and Assistant Dean. He is currently serving as a member of the Association for Continuing Higher Education Board of Directors. He twice served as the Chair of the ACHE - New England region and three times as the editor of the Proceedings of the ACHE national conferences. His area of expertise include program and curriculum development, student learning outcomes assessment, adult student retention, accreditation, and faculty development and appraisal. He has given workshops, invited addresses, and keynote presentations on a variety of topics at academic conferences throughout the country and regularly serves as an evaluator for the New England Commission of Higher Education.
Explore more content like this article
Clinical Mental Health Instructor Dr. Damion Cummins: A Faculty Q&A
Dr. Damion Cummins found his passion for counseling during his recovery from a life-altering sports injury. Now he teaches students in Southern New Hampshire University's master's in clinical mental health counseling so they can begin careers counseling others.
What is Psychometrics? How Assessments Help Make Hiring Decisions
Psychometrics refers to the field in psychology related to testing, measurement, and assessment. Using psychometrics, employers are able to make some hiring and staffing decisions based on the information provided from tools such as personality tests.
Clinical Mental Health Instructor Dr. Valerie Balog: A Faculty Q&A
After more than a decade at North Carolina universities, Dr. Valerie Balog joined Southern New Hampshire University's master's in clinical mental health counseling faculty.